Monday, November 5, 2012

Why Take Risks?

An academic paper that attempts to prove what climbers already know: there's a benefit in the risk inherent in climbing. That, alone, can justify the activity. (The authors write specifically about mountaineering but I think their thesis applies to all risk-based sports.)

One point they make about risk, is that if all of the risk were removed from mountaineering, it wouldn't be as appealing. So the benefits of the risks/dangers help answer the question: "Why would you do something that's dangerous?" Here is part of their conclusion:

"On the other hand, risk-taking is good in relation to the value of .. certain ‘experiential’ goods. Two are particularly notable. One is that risk-taking can make one ‘feel alive’ and ‘in the zone’. This may take multifarious forms. It can involve a supercharged adrenaline rush; but it can also have a more serene, meditative and sublime exhilarative quality....These quite intense experiences of utter exhilaration often extend long after the real danger is over and can give rise to a sense of personal fulfillment. A second value.. concerns the ways mountaineers experience themselves as agents. Again this has numerous dimensions. It can involve quite simply experiencing yourself as an effective agent: in general terms, you achieve the things you set out to achieve by competently overcoming the risks constitutive of the challenges you set yourself; at a more specific level, the experience of moving competently (fluently, in control) through the medium in which you are climbing gives rise to a deeply 
gratifying experience of effective agency."



Table 1: Risk of death with sports activities


Cause of Death
Country
Year
Number of Deaths
Population Estimate
Crude Rate per 100,000 population
Odds of Dying
(1 in )
BASE JumpingNorway (Kjerag Massif)
1995-2005
9
20,850
43.17
2,317 jumps
SwimmingGermany
1997-2006
31
1,754,182
1.77
56,587
CyclingGermany
1997-2006
19
1,754,182
1.08
92,325
RunningGermany
1997-2006
18
1,754,182
1.03
97,455
SkydivingUS
2006
21
2,122,749
0.99
101,083 jumps
Sweden
1994-2003
9
1,126,704
0.80
125,189
FootballGermany
1997-2006
17
1,754,182
0.97
103,187
Hang-glidingUK
0.86
116,000 flights
TennisGermany
1997-2006
15
1,754,182
0.86
116,945
Sudden cardiac death whilst running a marathonUS
1975-2005
26
3,292,268
0.79
126,626 runners
Horse RidingGermany
1997-2006
10
1,754,182
0.57
175,418
American FootballUS
1994-1999 (average annual figures)
6
1,100,142
0.55
182,184
Scuba DivingUK
200,000 dives
Table TennisGermany
1997-2006
7
1,754,182
0.40
250,597
Rock ClimbingUK
0.31
320,000 climbs
CanoeingUK
0.13
750,000 outings
SkiingUS
2002/2003
37
57,600,000
0.06
1,556,757 visits




No comments: